創作內容

5 GP

對同人誌的一些感想

作者:首領八奇│2010-06-04 22:23:58│巴幣:2│人氣:523
踏入閱讀同人誌界這麼多年了,有股感想與不快始終盤繞腦海,揮之不去。
今天這篇打算一次說個明白當作發洩,但因為語氣問題,改用英文表現。也許哪天更火大會補上中文也說不定XD






In my opinion, most of what we so called "Doujinshi" are just a pile of shit, unfortunately. Nothing but cheap crap. Those books totally lack of story, even basic logic or morality. The only thing these artists of the books concern is how to make these fiction girls have sexual intercourse with male characters(what if there's no male role in origin comics? Just fucking create one! So there he comes, a man with no facial features. The oringnal background story? Eat shit and die!) So there's the problem, those doujinshis are full of echi scenes, with wonderful and lovely works maybe, but the plot... hun? Do they have it? God damned it! How dare you call that junk a story?


In the other hand, however, the quality of Yuri doujinshi is much better. I'm not saying that Yuri doujinshsis are absolutely better than normal doujinshis, but Yuri one is usually superior to normal one. The artists of Yuri doujinshi take more efforts to write a good story, describe the tiny changing of relationship between two charaters and all these make teh level of Yuri doujinshis higher. I guess that's a part of reason why I prefer Yuri. The good quality of story, my friends. Not just for echi, not just base on physiological needs to publish it.


Why should I care? After all, I can just ignore those fucking awful books. They can eat shit and die for all I care. Nevertheless, the thing really annoying me is the market mechanism doesn't work in this. The poor shit is all over the stores, yet the customers seem to get used to it. I believe most readers would reject the meaning of doujinshi is equal to porn books. But damn, let's just face the music! The only advantage in a book is not its plot, not its edification but its jucy echi scene, how can we announce, argue that it's not a porn book? We made this situation. We convince other people to ban doujinshi or get it under highly control. WE must take responsibility.
引用網址:https://home.gamer.com.tw/TrackBack.php?sn=979754
All rights reserved. 版權所有,保留一切權利

相關創作

同標籤作品搜尋:|同人誌|心情|感想|

留言共 5 篇留言

給我凱特
我覺得你對同人誌真的很有愛, 所以才會想那麼多吧.
我的要求就沒你高了, 我不會太注重故事, 有好故事的話當然更加分,
我比較在意的是角色有沒有符合原本故事中的角色特質.
And yes, We ARE the Fuxking market !

06-04 23:15

首領八奇
因為我要對某一作品相當有愛,才會開始去看它的同人誌。也正是因為這份愛,我討厭劇情甲賽只有H的玩意。~.~


也許我的標準真的是嚴格了點...06-05 11:47
QQ獸
什麼都..

看不懂 囧

06-05 02:45

首領八奇
也許這樣也好。XD06-05 11:48
阿空空
看不懂...
不過用了翻譯有看到一些不雅(?)的字眼
或許應該要找好點的翻翻看..

06-06 02:52

首領八奇
不雅字眼不必翻譯也知道呀,因為第一句就出現了。XD06-06 12:37
煦天熾雪
雖然沒有去細看(我英文沒有頂好啊XD),不過從一些部分
就可以看出……大大對於品質的「要求」。

看作品(官方或同人),抑或是寫小說,都會擔心「崩壞」
、「違和」,原因無他--如果這種狀況產生了,那真的
還是這部作品嗎?(刻意除外)

有這種程度上的要求,才有真正好的作品出現吧。不然,
作品的內涵堪憂啊。

部分推論,冒犯請見諒~

06-20 10:55

首領八奇
我主要要求的事故事的品質,同時非常討厭插入原作沒有的角色(無臉男)。
大部分的同人誌在我看來只不過是種生理需求的產物,完全不合格呀。06-20 12:48
林桑
寫的太中肯了!
華麗的餐桌裡的高園寺牧人也說過就算沒有身體和身體連在一起的關係,
也還有心和心連在一起的關係,
搞不懂為什麼那麼多人都只畫些身體和身體的...(搖頭+嘆氣)

09-25 16:33

我要留言提醒:您尚未登入,請先登入再留言

5喜歡★mengskstalin 可決定是否刪除您的留言,請勿發表違反站規文字。

前一篇:[幸運星同人] The ... 後一篇:[幸運星同人] The ...

追蹤私訊切換新版閱覽

作品資料夾

KKTarta大家
歡迎來小屋閱讀原創異世界輕小說作品!看更多我要大聲說5小時前


face基於日前微軟官方表示 Internet Explorer 不再支援新的網路標準,可能無法使用新的應用程式來呈現網站內容,在瀏覽器支援度及網站安全性的雙重考量下,為了讓巴友們有更好的使用體驗,巴哈姆特即將於 2019年9月2日 停止支援 Internet Explorer 瀏覽器的頁面呈現和功能。
屆時建議您使用下述瀏覽器來瀏覽巴哈姆特:
。Google Chrome(推薦)
。Mozilla Firefox
。Microsoft Edge(Windows10以上的作業系統版本才可使用)

face我們了解您不想看到廣告的心情⋯ 若您願意支持巴哈姆特永續經營,請將 gamer.com.tw 加入廣告阻擋工具的白名單中,謝謝 !【教學】